If we can cook it, you can cook it!

Upstate Scalloped Potatoes

Upstate Scalloped Potatoes

Make these wonderful potatoes for Easter or Passover!

Sam Sifton of The New York Times sends out emails with alarming frequency.  And of course,  I read every one. This week is particularly notable in that Passover starts tomorrow night, April 15th which is also Good Friday.  So after the 40 days of Lent, Easter Sunday will be a Feast Day for many of us. Sifton covers everything from soup to nuts. But I was particularly pleased that he included this great recipe for a great favorite in our house. The Scalloped Potato. Now, this dish doesn’t often make an appearance because you cook Scalloped Potatoes for a crowd. It’s not like a baked potato that practices portion control all by itself. Instead, this casserole of thinly sliced potatoes requires a little more time and effort.  And in the case of this recipe, we loved it so much the first time, that we are delighted to re-introduce it to you, just in time for the holidays.

What made us love this recipe before we ever tasted it? This review:

“Little tiny town…no cippolinis, used a regular sweet yellow onion. No leeks, used green onions. No fresh tarragon, used fresh thyme and chives. Added good parmesan, couple of handfuls, to the top. OH my gosh…if it was this good after I boogered the recipe up, what must it be like using the original and authentic? Thank you, sir, for a wonderful recipe…we will have it once a year, at Christmas, I think.” Jonna.  She was apparently not alone in her review.  The recipe had, at last count, 237 Five Star ratings.  It also falls into the category of make-ahead recipes for either Holiday.  In fact, it benefits from a few days in the fridge where it firms up and when re-heated it will slice into perfect wedges rather than slithering all over the plate.

Cheryl Rogowski is a farmer in Orange County, New York

The recipe was accompanied by this story in the Times.

“This recipe comes from Cheryl Rogowski, whose family has been farming the rich black earth on their patch of Orange County, N.Y., for more than 50 years. They started growing Keuka Golds because the two best-known potatoes in the country — russets and Yukon Golds — did not grow well there. Keukas have yellow flesh, rich flavor, and pale skin like Yukons, but they can handle the region’s drastic temperature swings, short growing season, divergent soils, and uneven rainfall. For this dish, Yukons work equally well.” No Yukons? Go with Russets!

Since Yukons grow right down the road from us in Bridgehampton

That’s what we used and the results were every bit as satisfying as Jonna’s were. And we followed the recipe to a Tee.  What’s involved here is infusing heavy cream with three different onion flavors—leeks, garlic, and Cipollini onions all minced in the Cuisinart.  Into the cream went potatoes sliced with a mandoline 1/8 inch thick. They softened and sapped up the cream.   This is the point in the recipe when you can layer the potatoes in a pie plate, seal it very tight and refrigerate until about 1 hour and 15 minutes before you serve them. With any luck, you’ll achieve a ‘potato pie’ that you can cut into wedges and serve. Here is the recipe.


Upstate Scalloped Potatoes from Cheryl Rogowski of Orange County, New York

April 14, 2022
: 12 wedges
: 10 min
: 1 hr 40 min
: 1 hr 50 min
: Easy

This recipe makes a superb potato pie which can be cut into wedges for serving. Tarragon and Cipollini onions give it a unique flavor...but as the story says, feel free to substitute chives and regular onions.


  • 3 tablespoons butter, more for greasing pie plate
  • 4 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1 medium leek, white and light green parts only, minced
  • 4 small cipollini onions, minced
  • 2 tablespoons minced French tarragon leaves plus 1 tablespoon finely chopped, for garnish
  • 3 cups heavy cream
  • 2 pounds (about 6 medium) Keuka Gold potatoes (unpeeled), sliced 1/8-inch thick
  • Salt
  • Ground white pepper
  • Step 1 Heat oven to 350 degrees. Butter a 9-inch deep-dish glass pie plate.
  • Step 2 In a wide saucepan, combine 3 tablespoons of butter, garlic, leek, and onions. Place over medium-low heat and sauté until mixture is lightly golden about 15 minutes. Add 2 tablespoons tarragon, the cream, and potatoes, and mix well. Simmer gently until potatoes are barely tender, about 15 minutes. Season with salt and white pepper to taste.
  • Step 3 Using a slotted spoon, transfer potatoes to a pie plate, spreading them evenly and pressing lightly to compact them. Drizzle with 2 to 3 tablespoons of cream from the pan. Cover with foil and bake for 40 minutes. Remove foil and continue to bake until the top is light golden brown, about 10 more minutes. Remove from heat and allow to rest for 15 minutes. Garnish with a sprinkling of chopped tarragon, and serve.

Related Posts

The Best Baked Potato?  Try Our English Jacket Potatoes!

The Best Baked Potato? Try Our English Jacket Potatoes!

Astonishingly, Baked Potatoes are trending in the heat of Summer. Almost every day, I check to see what’s hot on Chewing The Fat.  This week, I discovered that the most popular recipe on the entire site was “The Perfect Baked Potato”. With 4160 pageviews just […]

Has anyone ever made a Tart as Christmas-y as this?      Cranberry Curd Tart from David Tanis in The New York Times with a deep bow to David Lebovitz

Has anyone ever made a Tart as Christmas-y as this? Cranberry Curd Tart from David Tanis in The New York Times with a deep bow to David Lebovitz

I marvel at Andrew’s passion for baking. And it’s at its zenith at holiday time.  It doesn’t necessarily mean Thanksgiving or Easter or Christmas.. It could be Valentine’s Day or the 4th of July.. But I have to say that this year’s output at Thanksgiving […]

8 thoughts on “Upstate Scalloped Potatoes”

    • Yes! Although much more associated with California, Orange County, New York is above Rockland County on the Western side of the Hudson River. “Each of these was named to honor a member of the British royal family, and Orange County took its name from the Prince of Orange, who subsequently became King William III of England. As originally defined, Orange County included only the southern part of its present-day territory, plus all of present-day Rockland County further south.” Wikipedia

      • Interesting!! Thank you for that. We consider Orange County the Mid-Hudson region. Regardless, this dish looks so delicious it does not matter. 🙂

        • Dear Violet,

          This is absolutely delicious. I made it again for our Easter lunch and everyone raved about it and seconds were the order of the day.
          It’s well worth the effort and I won’t wait for another holiday to serve it. Thanks so much for taking the time to comment. Warm regards, Monte

          • I made this for Mother’s Day and it was a hit. I had to use thyme and Yukon potatoes, and then I also tried using 1/2 cup white wine and 2 1/2 cups cream. The cippolini onions are so good. Thank you so much for the recipe.

          • Dear Violet, I can’t thank you enough for taking the time to comment on this wonderful dish. I made this for Easter Dinner. Knowing how rich it would be and how averse to carbs some of my guests are, I was sure I would have plenty leftover. Not so! Every delicious last bite was gone! Now that’s what I call a hit! So glad you had one too!

  • Unless it’s a vegetarian household, Passover seders feature meat; a dairy accompaniment is a violation of Jewish dietary law. However, this recipe would be great for Sukkoth, when it’s traditional to eat lots of dairy.

    • Dear Karen, Thank you so much for bringing this to my attention and that of my readers. At the time I was wondering about the dairy component at Passover. I do apologize to anyone I offended. Monte

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.