If we can cook it, you can cook it And we'll travel the world to bring it back home to you.

Melissa Clark’s Buttery Breakfast Casserole

Melissa Clark’s Buttery Breakfast Casserole

The Breakfast Casserole is a particularly welcome dish over the holidays.

With school out and plenty of days off, breakfast becomes a much bigger deal. Melissa Clark’s contribution is a perfect brunch dish as well.  Its name has nothing to do with its butter content. It’s from its buttery base of golden-brown Croissants. Almost all breakfast casseroles feature bread of some kind, generally the staler the better.  Stale bread eagerly sops up the egg, milk, and cream mixture.  Here, Melissa used fresh Croissants. The croissants are toasted in the oven which achieves the same result as stale bread.   The Gruyère cheese and sausage are a classic pairing and they make for a wonderful surprise in the layers of eggy, custardy goodness. This dish would be a stand-out even if it didn’t offer one of its greatest assets: it’s easy to assemble the night before and then it’s popped in the oven an hour before you want to serve it.

The Breakfast Casserole is a relatively new arrival on the food scene.

I cannot find any recipe prior to 1970. There is a woman from Cincinnati who claims her mother-in-law’s family cookbook included a recipe for what she called the “Breakfast Dish” in the 1950s.  That recipe stuck to the basics of egg, milk, bread, and cheese. She left the protein pretty much up to the cook.  Ham, Sausage, Bacon were all listed as possibilities.  A breakfast casserole by any other name is…an Egg Strata.  Even then, the Strata recipe, which dates back to 1902, is made with layers of bread, white sauce, and cheese but contained no eggs at all.   Digging a little deeper, one source attributed the popularity of the Egg Strata (aka the Breakfast Casserole) to 1984’s The Silver Palate Good Times Cookbook by Julee Rousso and Sheila Lukins.  Since The Silver Palate Cookbook remains one of the best-selling cookbooks of all time, it’s likely that alone would have made the Breakfast Casserole supremely popular.

I made very few changes to Melissa Clark’s recipe. 

Since I used a larger pan (10 x14), I did up the number of eggs.  I also used a ‘roll’ of Jone’s Pork Sausage in lieu of the alternate Italian Sweet Sausage Melissa called for.  Although the recipe says that it serves 8 to 10, 5 of us hardly made a dent in this rich, savory dish with its beautiful brown top. Here is the recipe:



6 thoughts on “Melissa Clark’s Buttery Breakfast Casserole”

    • Dear Helene, My bad and thanks for pointing it out. I was using a 10 x 14 casserole dish. The original recipe calls for the standard 9 x 13 pyrex casserole. I upped the egg count to make up for the difference in the size of the dish. I do apologize.

    • Indeed it is! We are big fans of Melissa Clark’s recipes. In fact you will find no fewer than 29 recipes that we loved enough to include here. Enjoy!

    • I cannot think why not. The only thing is the size of the sausage. You might want to make sure you use the same 12 oz weight as Melissa called for in the recipe. Note that there’s a “Or” in the recipe.It calls for one of those large sausage rolls like Jones which I believe is a breakfast sausage. Bon Appetit!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.